Toilet wax ring vs rubber

A toilet repair kit is a crucial part of any toilet. A Leaky toilet valve can make you angry. It causes a sewage smell into your washroom and needs to replace it quickly.

Both wax ring and rubber seal are necessary to create an airtight seal between the floor and the toilet. These are malleable and easy to adjust with the toilet.

Our article will help you learn about the difference between a wax ring and a rubber seal. You can select a wax seal that suits your requirements.

Wax Toilet Seal

The wax is made from beeswax, petroleum and other ingredients, depending on the manufacturer. It provides a pliable seal between the flange and the toilet bowl.

Rubber Seal

A Rubber Seal can prevent lubricating oil in mechanical equipment by closing the spaces between the equipment’s moving and stationary components. It is versatile and essential for thousands of applications.

Rubber flange seals are built large enough to slip over the flange bolts and stay centered on the flange itself.

Which is better wax or rubber toilet seal?

A wax-free toilet seal makes clean-up easier. It is reusable and provides long-lasting performance. If you want to remove the toilet base with a wax ring, you’ll need to purchase another ring to reinstall the toilet.

Is a wax ring the best for a toilet?

Wax rings are the most popular choice for plumbers. These are made from beeswax, petroleum or other ingredients, depending on the manufacturer. These rings provide a pliable seal between the flange and the toilet bowl.

How much does it cost a plumber charge to replace a wax ring?

To replace your wax seal and reinstall the toilet takes about $100 – $150 in large cities and high-cost areas.

Why does your bathroom smell like poop?

It is a common problem in rarely used guest bathrooms. The P-trap of a tub drain has gone dry because of rare use. Water acts as a vapor seal in a p-trap, and when it evaporates, sewer gas can blow into the room. But the smell is like a sewer than poop.

Korky 6000BP Universal Toilet WaxFree Seal

Korky Universal Toilet Wax-free Seal is the most efficient waxless toilet gasket that provides everything that your toilet needs. This model allows a re-positioning system, so you can re-positioned easily according to your toilet settings. It is made of rubber materials.

This replacement equipment is sturdy and offers long-lasting performance. It is the universal fit model that fits perfectly with any model. This model comes with a red rubber that resists bacteria. It does not affect the temperature changes.

This toilet seal offers anti-microbial properties that protect against chlorine and hard water damage. This item takes less than 5 minutes to finish the installation process.

Key Features

  • Provide 10 years warranty
  • red rubber resists chlorine, bacteria
  • creates a tight seal
  • It fits with different styles of bathrooms
  • Resistant to chlorine and hard water


  • Long-lasting performance
  • Durable and universal seal
  • Allows re-positioning
  • Easy to install
  • Mess-free


  • It leaks quickly

Fluidmaster 7513 Extra Thick Wax Toilet with Flange

Fluidmaster Wax Ring prevents any leakage that is harmful to your bathroom floor. This model is compatible with the floor and below the floor waste lines. This toilet seal added protection and comes with an easy installation process. It also ensures you a lockage-free sealing that lasts for an extended period.

This wax ring comes with a Polyethylene flange that enhances its serviceability and quality. It is resistant to bacteria. This item removes the bad odors, the gas between the toilet bowl and the waste line.

This extra-thick wax seal ensures a strong seal and provides you with the proper positioning of the seal. It helps you to secure your toilet fit.

Key Features

  • Perfect for 3-Inch and 4-Inch Waste Lines
  • Ensures a water-tight seal
  • Includes Polyethylene flange
  • Provide a 5-year warranty
  • Come with extra thick protection


  • Easy to install
  • Helps to maintain hygiene
  • Last for a long time
  • It fits with most toilet models
  • Affordable price tag


  • Not thick enough

Check these factors before purchasing a wax ring or rubber:


Both seals are reliable and durable. These are made of different types of materials like rubber, silicone, neoprene, and foam.

Rubber materials are essential because it has anti-microbial properties. It provides excellent resistance to chlorine and hard water.

Height of the Flange

It is critical to choose the height of the flange on your floor. It connects the pipe with the floor. Few flanges are leveled with the floor, some are placed higher, and some are beneath the floor.


All reliable products will provide a warranty that will protect your product break or is a fault. Few brands give 10 years, a few are 5 years, and some have a 1-year warranty.

So, before purchasing a new wax seal, you must check the warranty for the product. It will help if you choose more than three years of warranty product.


You can find wax seals with various thicknesses. These are perfect flanges that are set below the floor.

Drain Size

It is critical to choose the drain size before you purchase a wax toilet ring. These come in a standard size. Few toilet seals have flange built-in that makes the ring compatible with the different drain sizes.


Various sizes of toilet wax seals are available in the market. You should carefully find the right size that fits your bathroom floor.

You can also ask a professional plumber if you are not confirmed about the size.


Our article provides critical features and a complete review between the toilet wax ring and rubber wax ring. It is the most commonly used toilet replacement part. These come with a simple installation process with durable performance.

We think Korky Universal Toilet WaxFree Seal is the best option for you. Because it provides 5 years of service warranty, you can adjust it on most toilets as it has a 3-inch flush valve.