Extra thick wax ring vs regular

A toilet is a crucial part of any house. We need a comfortable and hygienic toilet in our home. Leaking toilets are unhygienic, dirty and not usable at all.

A wax ring is necessary to create an airtight seal between the floor and the toilet. It prevents leakage as the water passes from your toilet bottom to the pipe. It is malleable and easy to adjust with the toilet.

Our article will help you learn about the difference between an extra thick wax ring and a regular wax ring. You can select a wax ring that suits your requirements.

Can you use 2 wax rings on your toilet?

Do not be influenced to stack up two wax rings because this setup tends to leak. Placing an extra-thick wax ring will work much better in the long run. Place the wax seal on the closet flange, not on the toilet.

When should you replace your toilet wax ring?

It requires no maintenance and can last up to 30 years. But sometimes wax rings can dry out, crumble, and fail prematurely. When it happens, they need to be replaced. The telltale sign of wax ring failure is water leaking out from around the base of the toilet.

How much does it require to replace a toilet wax seal?

It requires $50 and $220 to replace a toilet wax seal, including labor and materials. If you are doing it yourself, then it requires $3 to $10. The closest flange also needs replacing, and it can increase the total project price.

Fernco Inc. FTS-4 4-Inch Wax Free Toilet Seal

Fernco Wax Free Toilet Seal offers you a simple and faster-installing facility. This item is elementary to clean and has a flexible maintenance feature. It prevents any leakage that is harmful to your bathroom floor. This item helps to maintain hygiene. It helps to prevent nasty odors and smells from coming out.

This Toilet Seal is adaptable for all weather conditions, and it is flexible. It fits with raised floors, tiles, wooden floors very quickly.

This wax ring is elementary to clean and has a flexible maintenance feature. It is highly adaptable and has excellent compatibility. This item provides additional thickness protection.

Key Features

  • It fits a 4-inch wax free toilet seal
  • Suitable for Floor Radiant Heat Installations
  • It fits perfectly with the drain pipe
  • Effective seal in preventing leakages


  • Durable and mess-free
  • Long-lasting performance
  • Easy to install
  • It fits any tilted floor


  • Wrong fits cause leakage

Fluidmaster 7513 Extra Thick Wax Toilet with Flange

Fluidmaster Extra Thick Wax Ring prevents any leakage that is harmful to your bathroom floor. It is compatible with the floor and below the floor waste lines. This item added protection and comes with an easy installation process. It ensures you a lockage-free sealing that lasts for an extended period.

This toilet wax ring comes with a Polyethylene flange that enhances its serviceability and quality. It is resistant to bacteria. It removes the bad odors, the gas between the toilet bowl and the waste line.

This extra-thick wax ring ensures a strong seal and provides you with the proper positioning of the seal. It helps you to secure your toilet fit.

Key Features

  • Perfect for 3-Inch and 4-Inch Waste Lines
  • Includes Polyethylene flange
  • Ensures a water-tight seal
  • Come with extra thick protection
  • Provide a 5-year warranty


  • Easy to install
  • Affordable price tag
  • It fits with most toilet models
  • Last for a long time
  • Helps to maintain hygiene


  • Not thick enough

Below these things to consider before purchasing an extra thick wax ring or regular wax ring:


Both toilet wax rings are reliable and durable. They are made of different types of materials like rubber, silicone, neoprene, and foam.

Rubber materials are the most effective because it has anti-microbial properties. It also provides excellent resistance to chlorine and hard water.

Height of the Flange

It is crucial to choose the height of the flange on your floor. It connects the pipe with the floor. Some flanges are leveled with the floor, a few are placed higher, and some are beneath the floor.


All good products will provide a warranty that will protect your product break or being a fault. Few brands give 10 years, a few are 5 years, and some have a 1-year warranty.

So, before purchasing a new wax ring, you must check the warranty for the product. It will help if you choose more than three years of warranty product.


You can find wax rings with various thicknesses. Extra thick rings are perfect flanges that are set below the floor.

Drain Size

It is crucial to choose the drain size before you purchase a wax toilet ring. It comes in a standard size. Few toilet seals have flange built-in that makes the ring compatible with the different drain sizes.


Various sizes of toilet wax rings are available in the market. You should carefully find the right size that fits your bathroom floor.

You can also ask a professional plumber if you are not confirmed about the size.


Our article provides a clear conception of the features and a complete review between the extra thick and regular wax ring.

We think the Fluidmaster Extra Thick Wax ring with Flange is the best one. This item is perfect for toilet installation and repositioning.

It can remove harmful sewage gases from entering your home. This model is adaptable for all weather conditions, and it is flexible.